#ConfidenceGap or ‘Nobody can make you feel inferior without your permission’

Since there’s plenty of time to browbeat, spam & harangue y’all into voting for our South by Southwest Interactive (SXSWi) panel about passionate people (please do vote early’n'often here, seriously), I wanted to riff on the theme of a spot-on proposal, discovered thanks to Rad Campaign‘s founder Allyson Kapin twitterstream (@womenwhotech).

Sarah Granger of WomenCount has an awesome lineup of women speakers on board to discuss ‘The Silent Majority: Women in Politics Online.’ Regardless of whether or not you plan to attend SXSWi, could you please click that link, create an account & vote for this panel as a favour to me? Please?

Timing’s spot-on, with scorching-hot political discussions about proposed healthcare overhauls & infinitely blog-able nutbars attending local townhall sessions.  Countering the divisive & anger-fueled ‘discussions’ occurring on this subject is an online space launched today, built by BlogHer & the Sunlight Foundation for women to share their thoughts on the healthcare debate. Users are encouraged to employ Sunlight Foundation’s roster of online tools, such as OpenCongress, to efficiently search & read the healthcare bill’s contents.  It’s telling that the first space online for public policy conversations by/for women is on the subject of healthcare, a public policy and private sector subject area that is in dire need of more estrogen after hundreds of years of male-only pharma trials & medical studies.

Hopefully by March this space‘ll serve as a case study for the ‘Silent Majority’ panelists to demonstrate that a large female audience will eagerly contribute to serious policy discussions when offered a space & encouragement; & this space‘ll also contrast sharply with mainstream media coverage of screaming match soundbites, insult-slinging & fear-mongering.

While it might seem ‘kumbya’ to state that these policy discussions would be more civil had they been shepherded by women, having worked for two whip-smart, balanced, strong & self-effacing female politicos, I truly believe that this is true & look optimistically to Kathleen Sebelius‘ ‘tenacious d’ throughout her career to deliver real reforms from the Health & Human Services Department in the months to come.

The clearest authoritative communicator on the touchy subject of lower participation rates of women in politics is Dee Dee Myers.  In her 2008 ‘Why Women Should Rule the World’, Myers devotes an entire chapter to ‘Closing the Confidence Gap,’ where she specifically lists verbal tics (starting phrases with ‘I think..’) & self-discouraging mental patterns that eroded her confidence while working in the West Wing. (More recently a Canadian expert scholar on this subject, Sylvia Bashevkin, published ‘Women, Power & Politics,’ which I’d highly recommend if you want a maple-glazed variety).

As Myers recounts her personal experience in one of the most coveted staffer roles interacting directly with news media, she supports her heartening &/or cringe-inducing anecdotes with research & interview quotes from biologists, sociologists & politicos (including Sebelius :) .  What made me think of this chapter within the context of BlogHer/Sunlight/SilentMajority was this quote from Harvard Business School professor Rosabeth Moss Kanter, which merges gendered discussion participation, voices online & confidence perfectly:

“There is no talent difference that I can see.  There is sometimes a difference between the men and women in the willingness to claim airtime in class.  The men seem to feel that they can start talking and eventually they’ll have a point to make.  The women are more likely to feel that they ought to have something valuable to say before they say it.”

We’re definitely lucky to have wry commentary coming frequently from bloggers such as Kadi O’Malley, as well as the many sharp female print jounalists from Canadian dailies extending conversations from their columns online, but we are unfortunately still at a loss when it comes to quantity & choice for viewing the political landscape through a women writer’s lens, professional or amateur.

Blogging about this at all means entering a loaded & delicate subject matter (landmines include ‘tokenism,’ ‘quotas,’ ‘man-bashing,’ etc.), but I feel the same as I did when I blogged in the winter to mark The Churchill Society‘s support of women in politics.  What’s changed is that with more collaboration between female writers online & the tools to synthesise information to suit a searcher’s specific policy interests, in the months ahead we’ll hopefully see more safe spaces built for informed female users to discuss specific policy issues, flesh out their views, disagree honestly & openly – without descending into name-calling.

#firstworldproblem

One of the oft-tossed phrases on The Twitter is ‘first world problem.’ Don’t know if it has jumped the meme shark, but it consistently serves a vital tone-defining purpose by allowing a user to whinge freely while communicating some self-awareness.  It’s a sly wink that in the grand scheme’o'things this croissant-less-cafe, super-long-supermarket-cue or obnoxious-TTC-seatmate is less tragedy, more inconvenience.

Two totally unrelated distinctly Canadian happenings over the summer have me thinking more about this phrase within the context of advocacy campaigns and public policy.

There is no shortage of interesting, well-researched, vibrant and thoughtful pieces written by political and tech bloggers on the CRTC hearings and the belief in ‘net neutrality’ – an issue that’s been close to my heart since the early aughts when interning at Heritage Canada and researching new media policies’ effects on our cultural industries.  And while it pains me to say this, not to undermine the many passonate people devoting energy to covering the hearings…I think we’re dealing with a #firstworldproblem here.

So I wanted to raise another #firstworldproblem, since we’re sitting here comfortably online in our sheltered homes or offices, powered by hydro, enjoying the interwebs (throttled or not) into the political blogosphere – howabout this summer’s TWO elections happening among Canada’s aboriginal population?  Any thoughts on the candidates campaign websites or the coverage or tools to monitor donations/events/promises?  Thought not.

With total affectionate bias towards the writer, I strongly believe that this piece by Waub Rice best reflects how the AFN election is both important and flawed in moving forward on issues affecting the quality of life of our country’s on-reserve native population.  Please do take a moment to read it to have a *glipse* of what it would be like growing up TODAY on-reserve across Canada where the speed of internet access is an unlikely topic of conversation.

Last month a blog post surfaced citing a very dated Stats Canada report (published 2004 using 00/01 datasets) calling this lack of internet access a ‘second digital divide,’ but mainly attributed off-reserve aboriginal Canadians’ rates of use to living in non-urban areas and tracking alongside non-aboriginal rural internet access trends.

Essentially, sadly, on and off reserve internet access rates and the overall lack of robust compelling information and potentially collaborative spaces online regarding the issues facing aboriginal Canadians, the composition of band councils, the election of chiefs and the AFN itself, is due to the lack of the basics for many – we’re not talking high speed/wireless/unthrottled internet – it’s electricity, computers and modems – and in many cases the communities have yet to be ‘wired’ themselves.

As the AFN process will undoubtedly evolve, as noted in today’s Globe’s encouraging piece here, internet access for Aboriginal Canadians will become much more important.  Hopefully within the next five years we will see an infastrucutre that supports on-reserve and off-reserve natives to have access to all candidates’ information and tools with which they can raise issues, coordinate campaigns and offer the same level of engagement despite a community’s location.

The same tools used to communicate the challenges of first-past-the-post or advocate for electoral reform in provincial elections in Ontario and most recently BC will hopefully be used to engage Aboriginal Canadians in a discussion around building a more representative political system.  That’s a #firstworldproblem worth devoting some energy, IMHO.

As they try to change their worlds, are immune to your consultations

Been reviewing relatively recent Toronto plan-undoings that involve citizens rallying around a piece of property & pushing back – online, natch.  What drew me to the first was plain’ol’personal interest & proximity – the No Big Box in Leslieville campaign.  Take a boo at their webpage - it’s nothing special.  But it worked.

The second was brought to my attention by a clued-in-colleague with a nose for all things green’n'municipal – the Strachan bridge offered up by Metrolinx.   This advocacy group’s site is even less stunning – how the heck do you navigate this thing?  Who came up with that rambling acronym? (stands for “STOP METROLINX Super-Bridge on Strachan Ave”, FYI) Where do those hot models live?  But it worked.

Finally, a photo-journo extraordinaire reported Home Depot’s foiled plans, which made us realize that local hardware handymen can’t do it nor can they help.   Although Home Depot cited economic concerns were behind their retrenchment, there was little to no local lurv & my *super thorough* online investigation includes year+ of grumblings & mumblings…

So wha’happen?

As much as I’d love to blame the developers for not wielding flashy splashy sites to dazzle & inform residents, it’s easier than that.

There’s nothing high tech, high falutin’ or high octane about the anti-project sites & their successful offshoots – Facebook groups & online petitions.

It’s the basic call-to-arms simplicity that saved the day in the two most recent examples.

Check your options on the No Big Box site:

  • Sign & Circulate a FAQ sheet or Petition (downloadable in PDF & Excel, respectively)
  • Display a No Big Box in Leslieville Poster in the window of your home or business (downloadable in 2 sizes, B&W or colour, in PDF)
  • Attend an OMB meeting (dates updated on homepage/only page & OMB’s website offered in case user can’t attend a ‘real life’ meeting)

Same with the Strachan’ites:

  • Regular updates from municipal & provincial politicos
  • Email blast cross-posted on homepage
  • Drive to petition, Facebook Group, Photo Gallery of plans

Although it’s far less straightforward than the Leslieville gang, it acted as a vital hub for anyone searching for information about the bridge & immediately offered actionable tasks to affect change.

From feedback posted by the publicspaceratti after new non-bridgey-plans were announced, the community appears pretty happy with Metrolinx’s compromise.

So what can we learn from these two successful online grassroots campaigns & one scared-off developer?

You can quickly frame the discussion & perception of a project by mounting a simple online campaign HQ that offers basic information, easy-to-understand & actionable tasks, & multiple off-shoots (petitions, Twitter, Facebook groups, e-mail signups, links to authorities) for your supporters to review, repurpose & redistribute.

Developers, investors, corporations & local politicians can learn a great deal from the momentum built on these sites, the frequent maintenance, updates, engagement, as well as the clarity with which they describe a problem/plan & offer immediate levers to send feedback.

Establishing in-real-life consultations – as well as concurrent online fora – is only the first step – executing these events & maintaining the web properties has to be conducted transparently, while prioritizing frequent updates, accessibility & ease-of-use.

Easy.

Hey, you scratched my anchor!

In the midst of some eye-opening on-the-ground-coverage in Iran & reflections on social media’s use in times of crisis, Twitter‘s been lauded as a tool able to bring ‘outsiders’ into the loop with unprecedented immediacy and increasing importance.  Most well-known & demonstrative of its role thus far were yesterday’s announcement that the US State Department contacted Twitter HQ to request the delay of scheduled updates to ensure continued information was broadcast from innumerable frustrated citizens & the underwhelmed disappointment with mainstream media coverage of the election among observers worldwide over the past week (a.k.a. #CNNfail).

When asked by friends to explain Twitter (often phrased as “Why the crap are you on your iPhone again, Rudey McJerkalot?!”), which happens a lot since this (flattering?!) bizarro world recognition, it’s hard to describe the scale & scope of the medium.  Depending on who you choose to follow, your daily dose of information via Twitter can consist solely of leaked hiphop mixtape bittorrents, horoscopes, localvore recipes, or salacious spam.

Like blogging, Twitter’s had a tough go earning the respect of mainstream media.

Lest I sound like a mohawk’d-Misfits-lovin’-kid screaming ‘Punk’s not dead!’, with every ‘decline of the relevancy of X’ article, there’s another useful voice popping up or staying vibrant online – be it on Twitter, blogs or holographic robot interpretive dances. The bad/boring/bored robots rust – this ratio of success:fail says nothing about the medium – the same can be said for unrecorded songs, unpublished poems & unsewn outfits.

Hopefully after this week’s umpteenth demonstration of Twitter’s usefulness beyond hype-y marketing forays it’ll stop being second-guessed as a fuel source to move forward an issue’s narrative.

Closer to home, & far more capable of describing the whats & whos of Twitter, are the computer whizzes at SysomosTheir report released on Friday is phenomenal. Some brilliant observations can be gleaned from just scanning the Summary if you’re tight for time, here are my favourites with my comments in parentheses:

-  21% of users have never posted a Tweet (Would most agree that the 1/5 ratio of ‘lurkers’ is the same for chat rooms & forums?)

-  72.5% of users joined between January – May 2009 (Mind-boggling growth rates, thanks to Oprah & Ashton)

-  65.5% of self-identified ‘PR Professionals’ have never posted an update ( hm. )

-  55% of users use something other than Twitter.com’s webpage version, Tweetdeck is #1 with 19.7% marketshare (could determine viability of pay-to-play or tiered membership offering based on how many users opt for paid mobile applications)

Hopefully the next generation of this report could examine the content overall to determine how many posts are Retweets (or ‘RT’s), sharing website URLs & messages to ask/reply to other users (‘@’s back & forth) – this might give us a better idea of how conversational the medium can be vs. the broadcast-y nature in which it has been characterized/dismissed.

On that nerdy note, I bid you adieu & hope our paths cross in music nerdery this week during NXNE

Special hat-tip to Count Gavin (a.k.a. Gavin Stephens – hilarious Toronto comic) for movie-reference-reminder….

Super Nintendo, Sega Genesis; When I was dead broke, man I couldn’t picture this

Will be blogging about the thought-provoking sessions at this week’s Politics Online Conference over the weekend, but wanted to whip up a quick post about a video that’s been circulating on political blogs.

Regardless of your views on the conflict in Israel, this YouTube video, featured on yesterday’s RealPolitix (highly recommended for non-partisan-tech-related-political news), called ‘Operation Cast Lead’ is a phenomenal example of the capabilities of online videos for awareness-raising, advocacy, lobbying and message-dissemination.

This simple, but extremely powerful 5 ½ minute clip uses simple narrative & archived news clips (old hat) – but in a first-person-shooter-video-game style to speak the language of a younger online audience & demonstrate the real effects of the conflict with a great deal of statistics and facts about the ongoing impact on civilians.

I encourage you to check it out either on YouTube, or on the RealPolitix site, where you can also read an accompanying positive pro-Israel write-up (best quote from the post “It is not an understatement to say that you can learn more from this video than you can from most of the media coverage.”):

No better time to be reminded of the power of gaming & visualization/advocacy/community than a couple days before pundit-izing on panels at the Canadian Gaming Summit.  If any Torontoians are geeking out this weekend, @me on Twitter & maybe we can sync up a study date – I’d love a fresh set of eyes for some PPTz :)

I got a lettermans sweater with a letter in front I got for football & track

Completely blissed out after having a very edu-mi-cational Tuesday yesterday.  Was very lucky to meet the enthusiastic crew of EQAO with Intangibles auteur, colleague & reformed protester Boyd Neil, when we presented concepts and examples demonstrating the impact of digital media on the education sector to our province’s communications professionals.

Wrapped the afternoon/early evening on my old stomping ground, UofT campus – Sid Smith specifically.  Like a reverse of Proust’s dunkin’madelaine, the 70s dystopian architecture brought back the faint whiff of Fung Mess Hall chicken fingers & recycled over-brewed coffee.  Long-time-bud-turned-expert-’crat & professorial-type Josh Hjartarson was misguided enough to expose a mess of malleable minds to my mad ravings on the subject of government relations.  Of course Josh was his always affable self, presenting with sharp quips, awesome examples and too-hip clips.  My jokes about Napster being free when I was in undergrad were met with crickets’n'tumbleweeds.  Le sigh.

Some tough queries from the always bright UofT PoliSci students that’re TEN YEARS YOUNGER THAN ME.  If y’all have any queries about what I *do* in GR…fire away…or click ahoy:

Finally, the most edu-mi-cational part of the day was discovering new music & meeting new Tweeps in the 2nd Twuneup Community (Follow’em @TwunesTO).  My pick out of all the the amazing cover songs? Beck+Of Montreal = AWESOME (not crystal clear recording…)

The hideaways, the nooks, they’re filled with good times

Two for two…blogger guilt is a powerful thing…

Wanted to send special thanks to blogger Mary for a lovely brunch in my fav Toronto haunt on Family Day – be sure to read her titilating reportage of our scandalous, witty, highbrow conversation in the days ahead.

Continuing the theme of shameless self-promotion – if you are one of the 8 people with Silverlight installed on your computer – feel free to cringe and wince along with all the grammatical fouls during my first french-language interview for TFO.  YIKES.  My Christian Bale-esque tirade filled with Crissedecaliseestidetabarnacdesacrament-s was sadly left on the cutting room floor.

Special invitation for all Torontopians in/around downtown on the 19th – Check out the Canadian Premiere of the doc ‘Us Now’ at Hart House, presented by Mass LBPFree ticket resos on EventBrite. Check out the trailer:

Stick around after the film for a panel of pundits, including Dr. Gillian Kerr from RealWorld, Author & InsidePR’er Terry Fallis, CBC’s Jesse Hirsh & our fav, ChangeCamp spearheader Mark Kuznicki.

all swallowed in their coats with scarves of red tied ’round their throats

Blogger guilt & the glimmer of spring prompts a much overdue post…Shamed into action by lovely stalwart scribblin’ colleagues like The Douma, The Doctor & The Boyd...I’ve now got Sharanwrap & Lunch Lovin’ Mary to keep up with.  Sheesh.

Certainly no lack of content to populate these pixels – followup from ChangeCamp’s kept things busy & continues to snuggles perfectly into my nerdy niches of politics, public policy, civic engagement, copyleft/opensource & tech.

(photo from Nate Archer)

Spearhead’er Mark Kuznicki has a great summary post on the ChangeCamp blog to succinctly wrap the event and issue a call to action for all participants to move our ideas forward.

Positive & constructive results are in for what was a hugely successful & ambitious undertaking – ChangeCamp Toronto.  Mosey over to the Wiki for interesting survey results & illustrations like this one:

While you’re surfin’ check out the glowing feature in the Globe & Mail about the open source movement in the city, & like all good tech events in TO, there’s a great vid by Mark McKay that captures the spirit of the event:

ChangeCamp ’09 from Mark McKay on Vimeo.

We’ve got more ChangeCamp schemes in the works, so stay tuned.  All planning meetings are broadcast/recorded to align with our ‘transparency’ thrust – we walk the walk, peeps!  Tune in on Tuesday afternoon for more CC chats & mind mappin’:

ChangeCamp Strategy Session February 2, 2009 from remarkk on Vimeo.

Water dissolving…and water removing. There is water at the bottom of the ocean

Howdy.  I know I said I’d blog more about transparency issues – but you can see right through me – I’m swamped.  This entry’s a two-fer & being cross-posted over here at the ChangeCamp blog, too.

Whoddathunkit? ChangeCamp blogger expectedly expressing love of transparency and, plot twist of all plot twists, turns out to be a lobbyist. Yeah, I just dropped the real taboo L-word.

So I’m @withoutayard, meegs to my friends & a registered lobbyist in the province of Ontario. And you may ask yourself-well…how did she get here?

Living in Austin during the last not-quite-as-amazing American federal election, led me to blogging & playing with online communications tools to affect change, raise awareness & spread awesome.  Returning to Canuckistan, I served a tour at the Pink Palace, but never quite mastered the mysterious machinations of political parties.  Unlike @dchartier, I couldn’t cut it in the civil service, even though sound recording policy at Heritage Canada was pretty darn close to a perfect policy-wonkette fit during a brief federal foray.

Combine the forces (read: career failures & bad-fits) & it sort of makes sense, right?  Witnessing the Dean machine go off the rails as a viral video trainwreck, seeing Meetup’s potential beyond UT Japanese exchange & making campaign donations as easy as Amazon blew my mind in ’04 (& broke my heart the night of November 2nd).  True patriot love of responsible government, parliamentary democracy & social justice/equity brought me home & hoping to see these transformative tools used in a Timmy’s.

I doubt I’ll ever get to geek out in a war room or a party HQ.  Partisan politics brings out the agnostic in me.  The thought of hundreds of thousands of dollars spent during a campaign on balloons, signs, buttons & miscellaneous paraphernalia drives me absolutely bonkers.  Working within the system, keeping abreast of legislative issues, regulatory nerdery & jealously eyeing the open source enthusiasm, technological progress & federal government’s paradigm shift to the South is a great fit for now.

Blogging about the last provincial & federal elections, especially the creative campaigns on provincial electoral reform & federal vote-swapping was encouraging.  A taste.   But not enough.

Enter ChangeCamp. Citizen-initiated, non-hierarchical, collaborative & generally all things old-school civics.  We have the tools, skills & thanks to some shindig yesterday in DC, the enthusiasm & momentum.  So let’s do some heavy lifting & make our standards for transparency and engagement the new status quo.  Liberate APIs, wiki-fy policy docs, de-PDF the whole shebang.  Easy.

I can turn back the hands of time, you better believe I can; I can make the seasons change, just by waving my hand

Wintertime & the living is slushy.  Despite the brutal barren wilderness & chill Canuckistan climate, hearts are warm in the centre of the universe for all things governmental/transparent/politicin’…

First things first – Event Plugs:

Wednesday, January 21stThe Churchill Society for the Advancement of Parliamentary Democracy is hosting a free Citizen Forum called “Parliament 2009:  What Kind of Country Will We Have?” at the University of Toronto Munk Centre.  Event details can be found here (on Facebook, natch) & here (on our org’s website).  The panel is stellar, the conversation will be oh-so-timely & a grand time will be had by all.  I’m encouraged to see many, many newbies already RSVPing – many from TO’s lively tech scene.  Cross-pollenation of these communities is vital & shows a genuine enthusiasm brewing to discuss our parliamentary processes, public  policies & – most importantly – developing solutions to increase citizen engagement.

The timing of the CSAPD event couldn’t be better, serving as the bass-heavy-rumbling thunder before the eye-catching-crackly lightening of ChangeCamp.  Originally assembled via Twitter, word-of-mouth & email blasts, we’ve now settled nicely into a GoogleGroup nest & would love to have you on board as a volunteer, donor or participant. 

Saturday, January 24th – ChangeCamp will be rockin’ the MaRS Centre across from Queen’s Park in crunchy unconference style.  Please do join us for a full day of positive, creative & thoughtful chats about Government & Governance in the age of Participation.

Tomorrow I hope to have a more content-y piece on the trends & activities behind the creation & popularity of these events…hopefully…darn it all to heck it’s been a lil’busy up in here.